Сравнение с Cursor / Codex
Публичная матрица из docs/CURSOR_VS_PROCOD.md (NTZ-100 §M3.1): 13 из 15 осей — winner procod с измеримым evidence. Подробности и команды воспроизведения — в документации и COMPETITIVE_SCORECARD.
| # | Ось | procod! (измерено) | Cursor-class | Winner |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Merge-gate / review governance | 100% golden merge-gate matrix (10/10); RV-01…06 IT | Partial PR checks; merge gate not first-class in OSS docs | procod |
| 2 | Audit export / tool-events | Admin CSV export + observability secret-related-events route | Usage dashboards; limited self-host audit plane | procod |
| 3 | Agent replay / rerun | Byte-stable replay harness; agent task rerun API | Task history; replay semantics opaque | procod |
| 4 | Command policy parity | 61/61 injection corpus parity IT | Sandboxed terminal; corpus not published for self-host | procod |
| 5 | Self-host / data residency | Full stack compose + privacy egress catalog in bootstrap | Primarily Cursor cloud; self-host not productized | procod |
| 6 | Team packs / org policy | PATCH /policies + manifest policy studio tests | Team rules; enterprise policy SKU | procod |
| 7 | Local-first offline edit | WB matrix + native FS errors + readiness gate | Local files; sync model cloud-centric | procod |
| 8 | Composer + rollback | Golden apply 100% (10/10); rollback in ComposerPanel | Composer apply; rollback not benchmarked publicly | procod |
| 9 | Indexing recall@10 | recall@10 ≥0.85 on fixture corpus | Codebase index; recall metrics not published | procod |
| 10 | Tab / inline latency | p95 ≤120ms harness PASS | Fast inline (marketing); no public p95 SLO | procod |
| 11 | Headless CLI / SDK | CLI branches 85.32%; OpenAPI + SDK smoke | Codex CLI / API (separate product) | procod |
| 12 | Cloud agent dispatch | Dispatch ≤30s SLO + review gate on cloud path | Background agents (cloud) | procod |
| 13 | Multi-provider tool loop | 3/3 providers tool loop PASS | Multi-model; tool-loop parity not measured | procod |
| 14 | Brand / marketplace | Focused workflow-native IDE; smaller extension surface | Large VS Code/Cursor marketplace | cursor |
| 15 | Managed cloud solo onboarding | Self-host path: Docker + dev:all (NTZ-100 M2 target ≤15 min) | Install app → sign in → agent in minutes | cursor |
Честные проигрыши Cursor: marketplace (#14), managed solo onboarding (#15). Источник строк: scripts/cursor-vs-procod-data.json.